Financial management is the process which is highly associated with making optimum use of money. Hence, planning, organizing, directing and controlling financial resources are one of the main objectives of business unit. Moreover, sound strategic and financial framework is high required for the attainment of organizational goals as well as objectives. In the recent times, stiff competition takes place in business environment which in turn closely influences the growth and success of firm. In this, by developing sound plan business organization can execute plan within then suitable time frame which in turn aid in the profit margin of firm. The present report will shed light on the extent to which inclusion of debt affects the financial structure and wealth of shareholders. Besides this, it will develop understanding about the level to which dividend policy of firm has an impac
A. Critically evaluating the impact of debt on shareholders wealth
Capital structure of the firm presents the manner in which it finances all the operations through the means of debt and equity sources. In the recent times, there are mainly two sources which are undertaken by large sized business organizations to fulfill the financial needs. Hence, company places high level of emphasis on the issuance of share for meeting the financial needs and requirements (Zsidisin, 2016). The rationale behind this, investors are always ready to invest money in the shares of firm which is highly growing. Moreover, it offers opportunity to the firm to make value addition in the money. Thus, by considering all such aspects business unit makes focus on the issuance of equity shares to the general public at large.
Along with this, companies also make focus on the issuance of bonds or debt instruments with the motive to fulfill monetary requirements. The reason behind this, debt instruments are highly secured which in turn enables firm to attract large number of investors. Hence, by taking into consideration such aspects business unit includes such two elements in the financial structure. According to the views of Finkler and et.al., (2016) debt is one of the main aspects that have high level of impact on shareholders wealth and company’s profitability. Moreover, debt instruments impose fixed financial burden in front of business organization. In the case of bonds and debt instruments company is obliged to make payment of interest to the debt holders whether they make sufficient amount of profit or not. In this way, bonds or debt closely influences the profit margin of firm. Further, such aspect also influences the dividend decision of firm. Moreover, company pays dividend to the shareholders from the profit amount which it has after the fulfillment of all financial obligations. In this way, dividend decision of the company is highly influenced from the extent to which capital structure of firm contains high debt.
In accordance with the views of Bir (2016) business units need to place emphasis on maintaining ideal ratio while determining the capital structure of firm. Ideal ratio such as .5:1 entails that company must issue 1 debt instrument namely bond in against to 2 equity shares. This in turn helps company in developing sound and effectual financial structure. Goal or objective of each and every business organization is to develop highly optimal capital structure which in turn helps in increasing the share price. Along with this, maintenance of minimum cost of capital is another main objective of business organization. In this regard, by following ideal ratio business unit can build and maintain highly effectual financial structure. The reason behind this, capital structure has high level of impact on the financial performance and profitability aspect of firm.
Along with this, such aspect also influences the profit margin of firm. Thus, for increasing the shareholders wealth and decreasing the cost of capital firm is required to lay emphasis on developing as well as maintaining optimal structure. Hence, debt-equity mix which increases the wealth of shareholders is recognized as suitable capital structure. Thus, by developing suitable structure business unit can maximize the wealth of shareholders to the significant level (Leland, 2017). For instance: If business organization wants to provide shareholders with high return then they need to include less debt in the financial structure. Moreover, in the case of bonds or debenture business unit is obliged to make payment of interest which directly affects the profit margin. In this way, by reducing the tax burden business unit can enhance its profitability aspect and thereby would become able to offer higher return to the shareholders in the form of dividend. Hence, by offering higher return to the shareholders company can increase the value of firm. Moreover, goodwill of the business organization is enhanced in the market when investors are highly satisfied from the return or dividend aspect.
However, on the critical note, Geske, Subrahmanyam and Zhou (2016) said that decreasing WACC may result into incline in the value of firm. Hence, by following such aspect highly optimal capital structure can be developed by the company. Nevertheless, there is lack of standard theory and framework which in turn helps in farming highly suitable or optimal capital structure. Authors stated that sometimes company focuses on including high debt with the aim to gain benefits in terms of tax brackets. The rationale behind this, interest which is paid by company to debt holders comes under the category of tax deductions. Hence, for reducing the tax liability firm makes focus on issuing debt to the investors. In contrast to this, Schepens (2016) claimed that high debt affects the trust level of investors to a large extent. Moreover, increasing debt level develops negative image in the mind of investors that business unit fails to meet the obligations more effectively and efficiently. In addition to this, increasing debt level also impacts future investment decision of shareholders. Moreover, along with the debt level interest expenses of firm also increased significantly. Hence, such increased level of expense negatively affects earning per share aspect.
Besides this, high debt impacts the level of investor’s faith significantly on the basis of bankruptcy implications. The reason behind this, at the time of bankruptcy investors get least priority in attaining back money invested at initial level. Hence, by taking into consideration all the above mentioned aspects it can be said that shareholder wealth and firm’s value is highly affected when organization introduces high or more debt in the capital structure (Lin and et.al, 2016). Thus, manager of the business unit needs to keep in mind all such factors while determining the financial structure of firm. This in turn helps company in achieving success in the highly strategic and competitive business arena.
From investigation, it has been assessed that due to situation of global crisis Tesco plc which is one of the retail business organization facing high level of debt. Global crisis occurs in the year of 2007-08 had negatively affected each and every sector including retail. Moreover, customers prefer to spend high on luxury only when their disposable income is greater. In this way, sales volume of firm is highly affected when economic condition is not highly effectual (Firth and et.al., 2016). Further, inflation and deflation are the major conditions which have high level of impact on the purchasing power of customers. Hence, with the aim to manage business operations and functions Tesco Plc has undertaken more debt. In 2007, level of debt was £16.7, whereas it reached on £24.20. It shows that for managing the business functions and activities company has taken more debt in the last 8 years.
Along with this, debt-equity ratio of Tesco Plc was 1.51 and 1.24 at the end of 2015 and 2016. Thus, by considering such aspect it can be stated that debt-equity position of company was not sound in the year of 2015 and 2016. Such ratio of company shows that business unit has generated high amount of fund through debt instruments rather than equity. Due to the rise in interest expense EPS of Tesco plc was reduced significantly after the period of financial crisis. Earnings per share of Tesco Plc were 0.36 and -2.12 at the end of accounting year 2016. Hence, by taking into consideration such aspect it can be said financial or capital structure of Tesco Plc is not sound (Glendening, Khurana and Wang, 2016). Thus, business unit is required to reduce its dependency level in relation to debt instruments. Moreover, high debt level resulted into rise in interest expenses which in turn directly impacts the profit margin of Tesco Plc. Thus, to develop highly optimal capital structure business unit needs to issue share in the near future. It enables firm to improve its solvency position and shareholders wealth.
By this, company would also become able to attract large number of investors and increase the value of firm. In addition to this, management of Tesco Plc needs to make focus on the formulation of highly competent strategic policy framework. For instance: By finding alternative and economical ways of performing activities company can exert control on its spending level. Besides this, Tesco needs to lay emphasis on offering high quality services to the customers. In the present times, high discount is offered by Tesco plc with the aim to enhance customer base. Hence, enticing purchasing decision making aspect of customers is one of the main objectives of Tesco Plc behind offering discounts. It is another main reason due to which profit level of Tesco Plc decreased over the time frame. Hence, for managing the business activities company prefers to take high loan. Thus, by making control on cost company can reduce the level of debt significantly. In addition to this, management team of Tesco plc needs to make focus on attracting large number of investors (LUO and WU, 2016). Hence, by issuing equity shares to the general public at large Tesco Plc can ensure balance in the financial structure. By taking into account all the above mentioned aspects Tesco Plc can overcome the difficulties to a great level.
B. Critically evaluate the potential impact of shareholders wealth on the dividend policy of firm
In 2007-08 global financial crisis situation had affected the whole economy to a great extent. During this period, several companies were compelled to close their business operations and functions due to the lack of fund. Along with this, banking sector is one of the main industries that are influenced to the significant level. Moreover, during the period of financial crisis high loan had been granted by banking sector to the individuals who want to invest money in real estate. Thus, it is the main cause due to which economy of whole world had faced the situation of monetary crisis. By considering such trend, Barclays bank has been selected to address such task. It offers depository and lending services to the customers as well as places high level of emphasis on offering quality service to the customers (Ullah and et.al., 2016). Several deposit schemes have been introduced by banking institution that directly contribute in the economic growth and development.
From financial statement analysis, it has been identified dividend which is offered by Barclays bank to its investors decreased significantly. Moreover, in the period of 2013 and 2014 dividend which were offered by Barclay bank accounts for £0.063 & £0.062. On the other side, in 2015 and 2016 cash dividend provided by Barclays bank was 0.059 & 0.052 respectively. This aspect clearly shows decreasing trend in dividend aspect of banking institution. Moreover, after the occurrence of monetary crisis net profit margin of Barclays bank reduced significantly. In the year of 2007 and 08 net profit margin of banking institution was 18% & 17.69% (Barclays PLC Dividend Date & History, 2017). On the other side, in 2014 and 2015 loss has been suffered by Barclays bank which directly affects its dividend as well as other decisions which are highly associated with the investors. Moreover, company offers dividend to the shareholders from the profit generated by it over all the expenses such as indirect, interest and taxation. Hence, dividend decision of firm is highly influenced or impacted from the profit generated by it during the year.
During the accounting year 2014 and 2015 NP margin of Barclays bank was negative such as -0.47 & -1.28. Hence, by considering such aspect dividend has been offered by banking institution to the customers at decreasing rate. Thus, high expenditure and lower profit level is one of the main causes due to which changes have been introduced by financial institution in the existing dividend policy (Financial statement of Barclays Plc, 2017). Usually, companies prefer to offer dividend to shareholders only when they attain high or enough amount of profit. However, with the aim to maintain faith in the mind of investors companies prefer to give dividend to the shareholders from retained profit. Similarly, Barclays bank has offered £0.062 & £0.059 dividend to the shareholders irrespective of the aspect that loss was suffered by the banking institution in the recent past.
Beside this, major cause behind the changing policy of Barclays bank is decline which takes place in the profit level. Moreover, after financial crisis there were significant decline in the saving and investments of people. Along with this, situation financial crisis has also created difficulty in front of business organization related to the recovery aspects. The reason behind this, after the period of 2007-08 there were several borrowers who not in position to repay the amount of loan. In this way, such situation affected liquidity position of banking institution in a negative manner. Further, due to the decrease in the interest level of personnel has also negatively impacted the revenue as well as gross and net profit margin of firm (Zsidisin, 2016). Thus, by considering overall market trend and financial position banking institution has taken decision in relation to offering dividend to shareholders at decreasing rate. Further, irrespective of the critical business conditions or aspects Barclays has provided shareholders with dividend each year.
Shareholders wealth has significantly affected from the change which is introduced by Barclays bank in the dividend policy. Attainment of higher return is one of the main objectives of investors behind making investment. On the other side, due to condition of crisis dividend has been offered by banking unit to the investors in a decreasing pattern or manner (Finkler and et.al., 2016). In this way, changes have been made by firm in the dividend policy has greater impact on shareholders wealth or return. Further, in 2009, debt-equity ratio of Barclays bank was 3.46. It shows that high level of debt has been taken by financial institution during such period with the aim to survive in the critical business situation or environment. In addition to this, from 2012 to 2014 debt-equity ratio of Barclays bank was greater than ideal ratio (Financial statement of Barclays Plc, 2017). Hence, due to the high tax burden Barclays bank failed to maintain high level of profit margin during such period. Meanwhile, EPS and dividend amount which is offered by Barclays bank reduced significantly. In this way, wealth of shareholders is affected in a negative direction.
Value addition in the money is one of the main objectives of investors behind making investment. Hence, by taking into account such aspect it can be said that investors prefer to invest money in the business organization which offers return in a steady or stable manner. It is one of the main aspects which directly influence the decision making aspect of investors. Moreover, company which offers steady dividend is considered as one whose management is highly sound and efficient. Further, stable dividend policy also entails that strategies and policies which are undertaken by firm is sound. At the time of decision making investors consider each and every aspect such as financial position and performance, dividend policy, payout ratio, earning per share etc. Hence, after making in-depth evaluation of each and every aspect investors take decision whether they need to invest money in the firm’s operations or not (Bir, 2016). Thus, dividend policy is one of the main aspects which are considered by investors while making plan about investing money. Hence, growth rate in dividend, competitor’s strategies and policies, profitability, liquidity and solvency position of the firm is evaluated by investors when they plan about making decisions.
Thus, by considering such trend banking unit has taken decision in relation to offering dividend to the shareholders. This in turn enables firm to develop high level of faith among the investors. Thus, Barclays bank needs to keep in mind all such factors while making decision about dividend policy and financial aspects (Leland, 2017). Hence, by maximizing shareholders wealth company can build its distinct image in the mind of investors and thereby enhances goodwill. In this way, by taking into consideration all such aspects it can be said that dividend policy which is proposed or announced by business organization has high level of impact on shareholders wealth and their decision making.
From the above report, it has been concluded that maximization of shareholders wealth and firm’s value is one of the main objectives of business organization. It can be seen in the report, attainment of such objective is highly influenced from the capital structure is setting down by business unit. Besides this, it can be revealed from the report that Tesco Plc needs to make focus on maintaining ideal debt-equity ratio such as .5:1. By doing this, company can maximize the wealth of shareholders and thereby value of the firm. It has been articulated that Tesco is facing difficulties in relation to reducing the impact of debt which in turn resulted into high debt. Thus, company needs to develop competent and strategic policy framework for enhancing the solvency position or aspect. Further, it can be inferred that situation of crisis closely affects the dividend policy of firm. Moreover, at the time of monetary crisis business unit does not have enough profits for distributing among the shareholders. It can be summarized that situation of financial crisis negatively affects the shareholders wealth and return.
- Bir, J. S., 2016. Knowledge, Attitude and their Effect on the Recently Graduated Employees’ Financial Management Practices and Satisfaction. Economic Literature, 12, pp.69-81.
- Finkler, S. A. and et.al., 2016. Financial management for public, health, and not-for-profit organizations. CQ Press.
- Firth, M. and et.al., 2016. Institutional stock ownership and firms’ cash dividend policies: Evidence from China. Journal of Banking & Finance. 65. pp.91-107.
- Geske, R., Subrahmanyam, A. and Zhou, Y., 2016. Capital structure effects on the prices of equity call options. Journal of Financial Economics. 121(2). pp.231-253.
- Glendening, M., Khurana, I. K. and Wang, W., 2016. The market for corporate control and dividend policies: Cross-country evidence from M&A laws. Journal of International Business Studies. 47(9). pp.1106-1134.